Almost every autumn somebody keeps pace with Bayern, and every spring Bayern pull away. This season’s version is Dortmund, level on 18 points after eight rounds and fresh from a 2–2 draw in Munich. Whether that lasts is the question German football asks every year, and the sixteen completed seasons since 2010–11 give a fairly clear answer.
Bayern have lost the title three times in that stretch. To Dortmund in 2011 and 2012, and to Leverkusen in 2024. Those three seasons share a pattern, and it is worth knowing what it is and what it isn’t.
How Many Points Does It Take to Win the Bundesliga Without Being Bayern?
Well, that depends on Bayern.
Dortmund won with 75 points in 2010–11 and 81 in 2011–12. Leverkusen won with 90 in 2023–24 and became the first club to go through a Bundesliga season unbeaten.
Bayern’s own title-winning totals since 2010–11 run from 71 to 91, so the target moves by twenty points depending on which Bayern turns up.
Dortmund’s 76 points in 2018–19 would have been enough in two of the sixteen seasons. It finished two behind Bayern. Their 71 in 2022–23 finished level on points and lost on goal difference. A good season on its own isn’t the problem. The problem is landing it in a year when Bayern have a poor season.
Do You Have to Beat Bayern Twice?
All three non-Bayern champions took at least four points from the two meetings. Dortmund beat Bayern twice in both of their title seasons, winning 2–0 and 3–1 in 2010–11 and 1–0 twice in 2011–12. Leverkusen beat Bayern 3–0 in February 2024 and drew 2–2 in Munich, so that was four points.
Four points are no guarantee, however. Gladbach took four off Bayern in 2014–15, a 0–0 at home and a 2–0 win in Munich, and finished third while Bayern won the league by ten. But no runner-up in a Bayern title season has managed it. The best any of them did was three.
Dortmund lost 3–0 at home to Bayern in November 2013, then won 3–0 in Munich the following April. Wolfsburg won 4–1 at home in 2014–15 and lost 2–1 in Munich. Dortmund won the first Klassiker 3–2 in November 2018, led Bayern by six points at the winter break, and then lost 5–0 at the Allianz Arena in April. In this sixteen-season window, none of the three non-Bayern champions took fewer than four points from their meetings with Bayern.
Which is why this season’s 2–2 in Munich probably matters more than it looked on the night. Dortmund have one point in the bank and one game left to find three more, at home, in March.
Does Bayern Have to Have a Bad Season?
By Bayern’s standards, yes. The three seasons they lost the title are three of the four lowest points totals they have posted since 2010–11: 65 in 2010–11, 73 in 2011–12 and 72 in 2023–24. The fourth low total was 71 in 2022–23, and they won that one on goal difference because Dortmund drew their final game against Mainz.
Coaching upheaval went with two of the three. Louis van Gaal’s exit was announced in March 2011, and he was sacked in April. Thomas Tuchel’s departure was announced in February 2024 with three months of the season left. It also went with the near miss, when Julian Nagelsmann was sacked in March 2023 with the title still open.
The exception is 2011–12, Jupp Heynckes’ first season back, which ended with Bayern second and was followed by the treble. So a coach on the way out is something that has accompanied Bayern’s failures, but not something they require.
Bayern have changed coaches in seasons they won comfortably too, so the change on its own means little. What the three lost titles have in common is simpler: a Bayern side under 75 points and a challenger who had already taken points off them. Those are the circumstances in which the Bundesliga odds tend to carry more than one name.
Why Did Leipzig and the Other Dortmund Sides Fall Short?
Each was missing part of the pattern. Leipzig’s two second-place finishes, in 2016–17 and 2020–21, came with 67 and 65 points and a combined one point from four games against Bayern.
Dortmund in 2018–19 had the points and the winter lead but only three from the Klassikers, and Bayern finished on 78. Dortmund in 2022–23 had the low Bayern total, 71, but took a single point from the two meetings and dropped two more at home to Mainz on the last day.
None of this is a formula. Three title winners are three data points, and Gladbach in 2014–15 show that taking four points off Bayern can still leave you third.
The seasons describe how narrow the path has been. Dortmund this season are on it. Level on points, a point already taken in Munich, a return fixture at home in March, and a Bayern side that hasn’t yet shown whether this is an 89-point year or a 72-point one.





